A: In most cases, no — unless the upgrade is something you want for cosmetic reasons.
Standard architectural shingles are already a strong, reliable option for our area. They’re thicker, more durable, and far better suited to our climate than builder-grade or 3-tab shingles. Most architectural shingle systems already come with high wind ratings (often up to 130–160 mph) when installed correctly as part of a complete roofing system.
Some premium or “designer” shingles do offer:
Higher cosmetic appeal (thicker profiles, specialty styles)
Slightly higher ratings for wind, fire, or hail impact
However, it’s important to understand how manufacturer warranties work. Many enhanced warranties only apply under very specific conditions, often tied to named storms. A named storm begins at 39 mph (tropical storm strength), while hurricanes start at 74 mph. That means the extra warranty coverage may not provide additional real-world protection in many situations.
In our region, wind is the primary concern, especially during hurricanes. The good news is that standard architectural shingles — when installed properly with correct underlayment, fastening patterns, and ventilation — already meet or exceed the performance most homes need.
We’re always happy to walk you through upgrade options, but we won’t push them unless they truly make sense for your home. If you love the look of a premium shingle, it can be a great choice. If you’re focused on performance, value, and long-term reliability, standard architectural shingles are usually more than sufficient.
Our job is to help you choose what’s right — not push unnecessary upgrades.